Simple test for presence of clear chromate
A discussion started in 2004 but continuing through 2017 . . .
Q. We are trying to confirm the presence of a clear chromate conversion on an aluminum extrusion. Is there a simple chemical (or other) test that can confirm that the chromate is there? Specifically, the coating is per Mil-C-5541 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet]E Class 3, and the base metal is 6063-T5 aluminum. Is it possible to determine that it meets the class 3 thickness? We are trying to avoid the costs of outside material testing.
- Cambridge, Massachusetts
TUTORIAL FOR NEWBIES:
Note the dates on these entries. In the meantime MIL-approved clear trivalent chromates (called TCP) have been developed; they are covered in more recent releases of Mil-DTL-5541 [link is to free spec at Defense Logistics Agency, dla.mil].
Q. My shop does chromating both clear and yellow.
Our testing indicates that we cannot meet the mil-spec with a clear coating.
At our shop we offer the customer the choice:
- they can have clear chromate, not certed to a spec or they can have yellow chromate with a cert
I know of no test you can do, BUT, I do know to get a truly clear coating you need to put on very light coating.
I would be interested in hearing if you find a test & if so, if your parts meet the mil-spec. I have posted this question here many times re: meeting MIL spec with clear chromate & some finishers respond that they do clear chromate & it does meet the spec - but no one referenced a specific QPL approved chemical to do this.David A. Kraft
- Long Island City, New York
I am an engineering student at a company that offers in-house chromating. Recently we've switched to a trivalent chromium to meet a new European directive that limits the use of hex chrome (among other heavy metals).
The problem I was facing with this new tri chromate is that the finish is practically invisible if no zinc plating is done previously. I was asked to find a simple test for the presence of chrome. Upon searching I found your site.
Our base alloy is 99% zinc so this might not work for aluminium. The process is as follows.
Lead Acetate Tri Hydrate [Pb(C2O3H2)2*3H2O]
Mix 50 g in about 1 litre of water. Filter for white precipitate or use acetic acid to dissolve. The solution should have a pH of 5.5 - 6.8
Place a drop of this solution on the part and wait 5 seconds. With a cotton swab, gently blot.
A dark deposit or black stain equates NO COATING.
The Spec for this test is:
ASTM ASTM B201-80 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet]
I suggest reading that first and also obtaining a proper MSDS for Lead Acetate.
This test is for Zinc and Cadmium surfaces ... Perhaps it is worth an experiment.
- Peterborough, Ontario, Canada
July 28, 2009
A. There is a newly developed trivalent chromium conversion coating two drop test kit on the market to detect the presence of Trivalent Chromium on aluminum substrates, Trivalent Tester LLC.James Savoy
- Columbia, Maryland
November 21, 2011
A. Dear Gentlemen,
Just make sure that your chromating solution is acidified to ensure that it is zinc chromate you are seeing on the galvanized material and not the aluminum oxide layer.
galvanizing chemist - Jeddah, KSA
May 22, 2012 -- this entry appended to this thread by editor in lieu of spawning a duplicative thread
Is there any way to tell, other than visual, if a part has been Alodined?
Manufacturing Engineer - Wrentham, Massachusetts, USA
A. Hi Tino.
Alodine is a Henkel trade name for a line of chromate conversion coating products. Some are for zinc or cadmium plating, but you are probably thinking of chromate conversion coatings for aluminum. We appended your inquiry to a thread which may answer it.
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Pine Beach, New Jersey
July 11, 2012
A. There are test kits designed to indicate the presence of Chromate Conversion coatings. I know Chemetall makes one. As I understand, they work by forming Prussian Blue on the surface of the metal but chromate inhibits this reaction.Scott Merritt
- Eastman, Georgia, USA
August 12, 2015
A. There is a test on the market to detect the presence of type VI hexavalent chromate, but it does not work on non-hexavalent type II class 3 chromate.
The test product is ChromateCheck swabs by 3M.
I have contacted several companies that chromate metals and they all tell me there is no test for non-hexavalent type II class 3 chromate.
- Tinley Park, Illinois USA
November 17, 2015 -- this entry appended to this thread by editor in lieu of spawning a duplicative thread
Q. How to identify whether coating is trivalent chrome or hexavalent chrome (chromate conversion coated aluminum sample)? Is there any test for this identification?K. Soni
Hi Soni. We appended your inquiry to one of several threads on the subject. If you do not find all your answers on this page, you might also review:
Letter 16365, "Determining if you have hexavalent or trivalent zinc chromate coating"
Letter 35023, "Estimating levels of hexavalent chromium in plated metal parts"
Letter 41067, "Hexavalent Chromium, how do I test for it on fasteners"
Letter 38996, "Amount of hex-chrome in Conversion Coatings for Aluminum"
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live "Aloha"
April 11, 2017 -- this entry appended to this thread by editor in lieu of spawning a duplicative thread
Q. Can you measure the thickness of a trivalent chromate topcoat over zinc? If not can you test for it's presence?Drew Howard
supplier - Rowlett, Texas, USA
November 22, 2017
Q. Greetings: We are a job shop metal finisher.
We are applying a clear, trivalent chromate conversion coating on sliver plated parts. Is there any test to qualify the presence of the chromate on the surface after it is applied to the silver plated surface.
Lab tech at plating company. - Phila., Pennsylvania, USA
November 24, 2017
A. The best spot test for the presence of hexavalent chromium uses 1,5 diphenyl carbohydrazide. A suitable test (even though it is directed at coatings on zinc, cadmium and aluminum) is described in ISO 3613 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet], Test Solution C ff. This test will work fine on silver. It is a pretty robust test.
Plating Systems & Technologies, Inc.
Jackson, Michigan, USA
November 27, 2017
A. Hi David!
You need to certify that the trivalent chromate conversion coating is there? Or you need to check if there is any hex chrome in your conversion coating?
If you need the latter, ISO 3613 is the test you need. If you need to check if you have any conversion coating, you could do a test like DIN EN 15205 (BS EN 15205 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet]) with and without oxidation (presence of hex chrome after oxidation tells you have trivalent chrome). This test is longer and more tedious but gives you much more data.
Hope you can check your results! Best regards,
TEL - N FERRARIS - Canuelas, Buenos Aires, Argentina
This public forum has 60,000 threads. If you have a question in mind which seems off topic to this thread, you might prefer to Search the Site